ZIP Code 11954 — Montauk, New York

    📍 ZIP code 11954 is in Montauk, Suffolk County, New York.

    ZIP code 11954 is located in Montauk, Suffolk County, New York. It is a standard zip code in the Eastern Time Zone with an estimated population of 4,073. The area code for zip code 11954 is 631.

    ZIP
    11954
    City
    Montauk
    County
    Suffolk County
    State
    New York
    Time Zone
    Eastern
    Area Code
    631
    Type
    Standard
    USPS City
    Montauk
    Latitude
    41.0464° N
    Longitude
    71.9488° W
    Land Area
    18.5 sq mi
    Water Area
    18.4 sq mi

    ZIP Code 11954 Map

    Coordinates: 41.0464°N, 71.9488°W

    ZIP Code 11954 Demographics

    Population

    Total Population4,073
    Density220/sq mi
    Median Age51.2
    Male / Female53.9% / 46.1%

    Income & Economy

    Median Household$129,375
    Per Capita$86,607
    Poverty Rate5.9%
    Unemployment5.3%

    Housing

    Total Units4,565
    Owner-Occupied80.7%
    Renter-Occupied19.3%
    Median Home Value$1,186,400
    Median Rent$2,061

    Education

    High School Grad96%
    Bachelor's Degree48.9%

    Population and demographic data sourced from the U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey (ACS) 5-Year Estimates. ZIP code routing data sourced from the United States Postal Service (USPS).

    Affordability & Profile: ZIP 11954 in Context

    The median home in 11954 is valued at $1,186,400 against a median household income of $129,375, a price-to-income ratio of 9.2. That is far above the 2.9 median across the 1,572 New York ZIP codes with published housing data, and well past the 3.0 ratio that marks an attainable market nationally, so buying here on a local median income requires substantial savings or a second income. Within Suffolk County, 11954 ranks 87 of 95 ZIPs on affordability (1 = lowest ratio); the county median ratio is 4.2. Renting takes 19.1% of median household income (median rent $2,061 a month), under the 30% cost-burden threshold.

    11954 ranks 214 of 1,572 statewide on median household income and 34 of 1,572 on median home value; its income is in line with the $128,844 Suffolk County median. 81% of households own their home, in line with the 80% statewide ZIP median, making this a majority-owner ZIP. 49% of adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher, far above the 31% median, and the poverty rate is 5.9%, below the 9.9% statewide ZIP median and among the lowest in the state. Unemployment stands at 5.3%.

    With 220 residents per square mile across 18.5 square miles of land, 11954 is denser than the statewide ZIP median of 197 (rank 747 of 1,572). This is rural or open territory where most of the land is agricultural, forest, desert or public land.

    Ratios and ranks are computed from the ACS figures above across the 1,572 New York ZIP codes with published housing data. See the 2026 New York affordability report for the statewide analysis and the methodology for definitions.

    Nearby Zip Codes

    Cities & Places Served

    ZIP code 11954 primarily serves Montauk in Suffolk County, New York.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    People Also Searched For

    Related Resources